|
|
||||
| By Colin A. Moore
Since September 11, 2002, we have been treated to the spectacle of police officers as law enforcement supermen. They have been portrayed as successful crime busters, innocent victims of terrorist attacks, national heroes, and paradigms of human compassion. This rose-tinted vision of police officers has blinded us to the seamier underside of the blue uniform that side of the police force that portrays all blacks as violent predators, that uses excessive force to apprehend suspects, that shoots individuals first and ask questions later. |
fellow officers, who very often, are the only corroborating witnesses at the scene of the brutal acts. Thirdly, there is a Civilian Compliant Review Board, which substantiates less than 5% of the complaints filed against police officers. Finally, there is a culture of tolerance throughout this nation, which is prepared to blink at virtually every egregious act of police violence and justifies it as necessary to protect the civilized community against the barbarian hordes "beyond the pale."
In picture: Councilman Charles Baron joining Wonita Young and other parents whose children lost their lives at the hands of the police. at a rally held outside One Police Plaza in Lower Manhattan, New York. Those of us who have been involved in fighting police brutality, have made several proposals to eliminate this pervasive problem. We have proposed that the federal government should take over the administration of the police department, should implement new administrative procedures, and monitor acts of police brutality. We have proposed that Civilian Complaint Review Board should restructured to become a fully independent investigative and prosecutorial body. We have advocated and encouraged the increased recruitment of ethnic minorities, until the police force reflects the ethnic diversity of the city. We have proposed the installation of video cameras in every precinct, and in every patrol car, so that acts of police brutality could be fully monitored and exposed.
Yet in spite of these proposals, the problem of police brutality continues to grow, not only throughout the city, but throughout the nation. It is like an evil demon that simply refuses to die, and every time we have consigned its corpse to the proverbial lake of fire and brimstone, it has risen, like the Phoenix from the ashes of hell, with renewed vigor and vibrancy. What is responsible for the continued vibrancy and pervasiveness of this problem? Is it because police brutality is more than an administrative problem that can be solved by amending a few regulations or procedures? Is it because police brutality is more than getting rid of few rotten apples or psychological psychopaths? Is it because eliminating police brutality is more complex, than electing a liberal mayor or a appointing a progressive commissioner? |
|||
| ____________________________ | ||||
|
Statistics on police shootings, death in police custody, and civilian complaints, show a clear correlation between police violence and racism. |
||||
| ____________________________ | ||||
|
times became corrupt and violent". The Commission observed that "as important, as the possible
extent of brutality is the extent of brutality tolerance we found throughout the Department. This tolerance or willful blindness extends to supervisors as well." In 1996, Amnesty International, in only its third report ever on a US Police Department, observed that, "police brutality and unjustifiable force is … a widespread problem, with a pattern of similar abuses occurring over many years." It further observed that "complaints of brutality have continued to rise" and that "the large majority of the victims of police abuses are racial minorities, particularly African-Americans and people of Latin American or Asian descent." Statistics on police shootings, deaths in custody, and civilian complaints, show a clear correlation between police violence and racism. Between 1994-1996, an average of 27 individuals were shot to death in questionable circumstances, with 90% of the victims being Black or Hispanic, while two-thirds of the shooters, were Caucasian police officers. Statistics on deaths in police custody were incomplete, but the available figures indicate that 23 people died in custody in 1994 and 53 people died in 1996. Again the racial pattern was clear. Eighty-nine percent of the victims were Black or Hispanic, and the majority of police perpetrators were Caucasian. Statistics on police shootings, death in police custody, and civilian complaints, show a clear correlation between police violence and racism. In 2002, 32 individuals were shot to death in questionable circumstances, with 90% of the victims being Black or Hispanics, and over 50% of the shooters being Caucasian. In 2003, 17 individuals have been shot to death, with 90% of the victims being Black or Hispanic, while two-thirds of the shooters were Caucasian. The most comprehensive profile of police abuse involves civilian complains of police brutality. In 2002, there were 4616 complaints of police abuse, representing an increase of 12% from the 4121 complaints in 2000. Although Blacks constitute only 20% of the city-wide population, they constituted 54% of the victims of police brutality. Whites, who constitute 35% of the city-wide population, constitute only 16% of the victims of police brutality. Thus, Blacks are three times more likely to suffer abuse at the hands of the police officers than whites. There are several factors that account for the high incidents of police brutality in New York. Firstly, there is the perception that most police officers who commit acts of police brutality will be exonerated by the Civilian Compliant Review Board, by the Office of the District Attorney, by petit juries throughout the city, by Administrative Law Judges or by the Police Commissioner. Secondly, there is the blue wall of silence, which protects police officers from incriminating testimony by their |
||||